Consensus Questions

  • Pre-hospital/ Emergency care
  • Irrigation and Debridement
  • Antibiotics
  • Scoring
  • Skeletal fixation
  • Soft tissue cover
  • Outcomes
  • VTE prophylaxis

Pre-hospital/ Emergency care

QUESTIONS
DOCTORS
PDF
1 Should tranexamic acid (TXA) be administered pre-hospital in patients with open fractures with active bleeding?
Dr.Christian Fang, Dr.Chetan Pradhan, Dr.Arvind
no pdf
2 In open fractures, is compartment pressure monitoring essential in uninvolved compartments?
Dr.Jae-Woo Cho, Dr.Siddharth Sharma, Dr.K P Srikkanth
no pdf
3 Should immediate reduction of protruding bone fragments or open dislocations be attempted in the emergency department prior to formal debridement?
Dr.Antonio Gardner, Dr.Ajith Kumar, Dr.Rajabhaskar
no pdf
4 Should preliminary wound irrigation with saline be performed in the emergency department prior to surgical debridement?
Dr.Roman Pfifer, Dr.Lalit Maini, Dr.BRW Armstrong
no pdf
5 Can regional anaesthesia be used in patients for pain relief before transfer to the operating theatres for debridement?
Dr.S Raja Sabapathy, Dr.Venkateshwaran, Dr.Mounusha
no pdf
6 Is human tetanus immunoglobulin mandatory in all cases of open fracture?
Dr.Michel Teuben, Dr.Unmesh Chakravarthy, Dr.Mohammed Zackariya
no pdf
1 Does a delay in surgical debridement beyond the traditional “six-hour window” independently increase the risk of deep infection?
Dr.Christian Fang, Dr.Chetan Pradhan, Dr.Arvind
no pdf
2 In Gustilo Grade III injuries, is it acceptable to delay debridement beyond six hours in order to await an experienced surgical team?
Dr.Fareed Kagda, Dr.Singaravadivelu, Dr.Gokul Dev
3 Should debridement be deferred until serum lactate has normalised in polytrauma or isolated long bone open fractures?
Dr.Chris Hans Pape, Dr.Vivek Trikha, Dr.Keerthan
no pdf
4 Should the timing of surgical debridement differ between low-energy and high-energy open injuries?
Dr.Hayder Al Saadi, Dr.Thirunarayanan, Dr.Harsha
no pdf
5 Does the use of a pneumatic tourniquet reduce blood loss and improve the quality of debridement?
Dr.Ravindra Bharathi, Dr.Vamseedharan Muthukumar, Dr.Roopesh
no pdf
6 Is the routine use of surgical magnification (e.g., loupes) recommended to enhance visualisation and improve debridement quality?
Dr.Ravindra Bharathi, Dr.Vamseedharan Muthukumar, Dr.Roopesh
no pdf
7 Is chlorhexidine or povidone-iodine the preferred solution for disinfecting extruded bony fragments prior to reimplantation?
Dr.Thierry Beque, Dr.Sushruth Babhulkar, Dr.Mohammed Asrar
no pdf
8 Is there a minimum volume of saline required for effective debridement?
Dr.Antonio Gardner, Dr.Ajith Kumar, Dr.Rajabhaskar
no pdf
9 Is there a role for pulsatile lavage during debridement of open injuries?
Dr.Kevin Tetsworth, Dr.Shailesh pai, Dr.Sahith
no pdf
10 Is a routine “second-look” debridement at 48 hours mandatory in severe Grade III or crush injuries?
Dr.Rodrigo Pesantez, Dr.Dhaval Desai, Dr.Aditya Yagnik
no pdf
11 Does photodynamic disinfection (light-activated antimicrobial therapy) represent a promising adjunct for decontamination of devitalised tissue?
Dr.Chris Hans Pape, Dr.Vivek Trikha, Dr.Keerthan
12 Should techniques such as laser fluorescence or indocyanine green angiography be routinely utilised to assess soft tissue viability during debridement?
Dr.Michel Teuben, Dr.Unmesh Chakravarthy, Dr.Mohammed Zackariya
no pdf
13 In patients with contaminated open fractures, does ultrasonic debridement compared with conventional manual curettage improve decontamination?
Dr.Roman Pfifer, Dr.Lalit Maini, Dr. BRW Armstrong
no pdf
14 Is aggressive initial debridement superior to tissue-preserving strategies?
Dr.Hari Venkatramani, Dr.Romi, Dr.Senthil Velan
no pdf
15 Can we objectively assess the quality of debridement in open injuries?
Dr.Emmanouil Liodakis, Dr.Ashok Gavaskar, Dr.Thiaghu
no pdf
16 Are mechanical suction drains effective for dead space management following debridement?
Dr.Marinis Pirpiris, Dr.Anup Agrawal, Dr.Terrence Jose Jerome, Dr.Surendran G
no pdf
17 Is the establishment of an orthoplastic service compelling in contemporary practice?
Dr.S Raja Sabapathy, Dr.Venkateshwaran, Dr.Mounusha
no pdf
18 Is a mangled extremity appropriately defined as simultaneous injury to at least three of the following components: skeletal, vascular, soft tissue, and neural structures?
Dr.Ronald Wong, Dr.Vasudeva Juvvadi, Dr.Muthukumar
19 Should the decision between limb salvage and amputation always involve two consultants?
Dr.Ronald Wong, Dr.Vasudeva Juvvadi, Dr.Muthukumar
20 Is posterior tibial nerve injury an indication for amputation?
Dr.Hari Venkatramani, Dr.Romi, Dr.Senthil Velan
no pdf
1 Should antibiotic-containing irrigation solutions be routinely employed?
Dr.Hayder Al Saadi, Dr.Thirunarayanan, Dr.Harsha
no pdf
2 Should prophylactic antibiotic administration be limited to a single dose, or continued for up to 72 hours?
Dr.Carlos Valderrama, Dr.Neeraj Bijilani, Dr.Sanjana
no pdf
3 In patients undergoing delayed soft tissue coverage, should antibiotic therapy be continued until definitive closure is achieved?
Dr.Peter Giannoudis, Dr.Durgaprasad Valleri, Dr.Rakesh
no pdf
4 In patients requiring multiple staged reconstructive procedures, should antibiotic therapy be administered intermittently or continuously until the final stage?
Dr.Mario Morgenstern, Dr.Sujit Kumar Tripathy, Dr.Lester frank
no pdf
5 Does the placement of an antibiotic cement spacer confer benefit for dead space management in segmental bone defects following debridement?
Dr.Marinis pirpiris, Dr.Anup Agrawal, Dr.Terrence Jose Jerome, Dr.Surendran G
no pdf
6 Do open pelvic injuries require a different antibiotic protocol?
Dr.Zsolt Balogh, Dr.Sithombo Maqungo, Dr.Abhay Elhence, Dr.Imran Asif
no pdf
7 Is there a routine role for local antibiotic delivery in the management of open fractures?
Dr.Kevin Tetsworth, Dr.Shailesh pai, Dr.Sahith
no pdf
8 In patients with uncontrolled diabetes mellitus, should the duration of antibiotic therapy be extended until wound healing is achieved?
Dr.Jae-Woo Cho, Dr.Siddharth Sharma, Dr.K P Srikkanth
no pdf
9 In farmyard-related open injuries, should empirical antibiotic regimens include antifungal agents in addition to anaerobic coverage?
Dr.Khaleed Emara, Dr.K C Sreekanth, Dr.Praveen
no pdf
10 Should IV cefuroxime be adopted as the standard prophylactic antibiotic, or should antibiotic selection be guided by local hospital protocol?
Dr.Vikas Agashe, Dr.Adithya Menon, Dr.Arun kamal
no pdf
11 Is there a role for oral antibiotics following primary surgical debridement of open injuries?
Dr.Ramasubramanyam, Dr.V.M Balasubramani, Dr.Sivakumar SP
no pdf
12 Should cultures be obtained prior to every stage of reconstruction?
Dr.Vikas Agashe, Dr.Adithya Menon, Dr.Arun kamal
no pdf
1 Is the Gustilo–Anderson classification system still a valid tool for classifying open injuries?
Dr.Sunny Parikh, Dr.Shanmukha Babu, Dr.Roopesh
no pdf
2 Is there a clear preference regarding the choice of scoring systems in open injuries?
Dr.Ramesh P, Dr.Navin Thakkar, Dr.Srinivas kambhampati
no pdf
3 Should open fractures only be definitively classified after surgical debridement rather than in the ER?
Dr.S Rajasekaran, Dr.Jamal Ashraf, Dr.Sindhura Yamajala, Dr.Suriyan
no pdf
4 Can existing open injury classification systems be reliably extrapolated to upper limb injuries?
Dr.Martin Jaegger, Dr.Venkatadas, Dr.Stefano Conti, Dr.Aadhavan
no pdf
5 Can existing open injury scores be applied to paediatric populations?
Dr.Martin Jaegger, Dr.Venkatadas, Dr.Stefano Conti, Dr.Aadhavan
no pdf
6 Are existing classification systems adequate for characterising open pelvic injuries?
Dr.Zsolt Balogh, Dr.Sithombo Maqungo, Dr.Abhay Elhence, Dr.Imran Asif
7 Are current classification and scoring systems adequate for predicting limb salvage versus amputation?
Dr.Sunny Parikh, Dr.Shanmukha Babu, Dr.Roopesh
no pdf
1 In segmental bone defects measuring less than 4 cm, is acute limb shortening to facilitate wound closure, followed by distraction osteogenesis, an acceptable strategy?
Dr.Marco Berlusconi, Dr.Ashok Shyam, Dr.Pushkar Chawla, Dr.Mouli Chandar
no pdf
2 Is there a definitive role for circular (ring) external fixators in the acute management of open injuries with bone loss?
Dr.Devendra, Dr.Milind Chaudhary, Dr.Govardhan, Dr.Raahul, Dr.Arjun
no pdf
3 In open injuries with segmental bone defects, is the Masquelet technique preferable to distraction osteogenesis?
Dr.Peter Giannoudis, Dr.Durgaprasad Valleri, Dr.Rakesh
no pdf
4 Is primary autologous bone grafting recommended for critical bone defects following adequate debridement and stabilisation?
Dr.S Rajasekaran, Dr.Jamal Ashraf, Dr.Sindhura Yamajala, Dr.Suriyan
no pdf
5 Is 14 days an absolute safe interval for conversion from external fixation to internal fixation?
Dr.N.K.Kanakaris, Dr.Owais Ahemad, Dr.Ashutosh
no pdf
6 Should early conversion from external to internal fixation be guided by serum procalcitonin trends rather than fixed time intervals?
Dr.N.K.Kanakaris, Dr.Owais Ahemad, Dr.Ashutosh
no pdf
7 Is bone transport (distraction osteogenesis) performed underneath a flap, a safe and effective primary management for bone defects?
Dr.Dheenadhayalan, Dr.Vetrivel Chezian, Dr.Nagashree V, Dr.Varsha
no pdf
8 In open injuries with segmental bone loss, should primary stabilisation using a Limb Reconstruction System (LRS) be preferred over conventional external fixation?
Dr.Dheenadhayalan, Dr.Vetrivel Chezian, Dr.Nagashree V, Dr.Varsha
no pdf
9 Are there well-defined criteria for performing definitive internal fixation immediately after index debridement?
Dr.Emmanouil Liodakis, Dr.Ashok Gavaskar, Dr.Thiaghu
no pdf
10 Should vascular shunting be performed prior to definitive bone fixation to minimise warm ischaemia time, or should it follow bony fixation?
Dr.Vincenzo Giordano, Dr.Samarth Mittal, Dr.Harish
no pdf
11 In major crush injuries of the upper limb, should limb salvage be prioritised due to the limited availability of prosthesis?
Dr.Alvaro Zamorano, Dr.Kateros Konstantinos, Dr.Sibin, Dr.Rithabh kumar
no pdf
12 Can critically important extruded articular bone fragments (e.g., talus or femoral condyle), retrieved from the injury site despite contamination, be safely reimplanted following appropriate decontamination?
Dr.Fareed Kagda, Dr.Singaravadivelu, Dr.Gokul Dev
1 In open injuries that have undergone adequate debridement, is primary wound closure acceptable in the absence of skin loss?
Dr.Rahat Jarayabhand, Dr.Rajiv Chatterjee, Dr.Velmurugesan, Dr.Thirumurugan
no pdf
2 Which local flap procedures should all orthopaedic trauma surgeons be trained to perform in emergencies?
Dr.Rajendra Nahate, Dr.Praveen Bharadwaj, Dr.Vigneshwaran
no pdf
3 When used as a bridge to definitive closure, does NPWT significantly reduce infection risk compared with saline-soaked gauze dressings?
Dr.Ahmad Arief, Dr.Raju Iyyengar, Dr.Imran Asif
no pdf
4 Can biological dressings (e.g., temporary skin substitutes) effectively prevent cortical bone necrosis while awaiting definitive flap coverage?
Dr.Rajendra Nahate, Dr.Praveen Bharadwaj, Dr.Vigneshwaran
no pdf
5 Should 72 hours be regarded as the cut-off when distinguishing “early” from “delayed” soft tissue coverage?
Dr.Rahat Jarayabhand, Dr.Velmurugesan, Dr.Rajiv Chatterjee, Dr.Thirumurugan
no pdf
6 Is there a role for simultaneous fix and flap in open injuries?
Dr.Devendra A, Dr.Milind Chaudhary, Dr.Govardhan, Dr.Raahul, Dr.Arjun
no pdf
7 What constitutes the optimal suction pressure and duration in NPWT?
Dr.Alvaro Zamorano, Dr.Kateros Konstantinos, Dr.Sibin, Dr.Rithabh kumar
no pdf
8 What is the role of continuous irrigation with negative pressure dressings designed for instillation therapy?
Dr.Mario Morgenstern, Dr.Sujit Kumar Tripathy, Dr.Lester frank
no pdf
1 Should outcome registries for open fractures be globally standardised to enhance the accuracy of prognostic models?
Dr.Thierry Beque, Dr.Sushruth Babhulkar, Dr.Mohammed asrar
no pdf
2 Should return to work status be utilised as a primary outcome measure in open fractures?
Dr.Vincenzo Giordano, Dr.Samarth Mittal, Dr.Harish
no pdf
3 Should patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) be prioritised over objective clinical metrics in assessing the success of limb salvage?
Dr.Wael Taha, Dr.Santosh Ram Gaddam, Dr Hemraj Bhaskar
no pdf
4 Is the long-term functional outcome following early amputation superior to that of delayed amputation after failed limb salvage?
Dr.Marco Berlusconi, Dr.Ashok Shyam, Dr.Pushkar Chawla, Dr.Mouli Chandar
no pdf
5 Does concomitant traumatic brain injury significantly accelerate fracture union in open injuries?
Dr.Ramesh P, Dr.Navin Thakkar, Dr.Srinivas kambhampati
no pdf
1 Are low-dose heparin, aspirin, or apixaban equally effective alternatives to low molecular weight heparin (LMWH) for VTE prophylaxis following fixation of open fractures?
Dr.Carlos Valderrama, Dr.Neeraj Bijilani, Dr.Sanjana
no pdf
2 Are mechanical prophylactic measures (e.g., intermittent pneumatic compression devices applied to the uninjured limb) sufficient as sole VTE prevention during the acute phase of open fracture management?
Dr.Wael Taha, Dr.Santosh Ram Gaddam, Dr.Hemraj Bhaskar
no pdf